
Heroic underdog sports films are a dime a dozen, as are pandering "special people" melodramas. Recently, Tropic Thunder understood it perfectly, warning actors to never go "full retard". Unfortunately, actors will continue to do this in their bid for sweet Oscar gold, and in a few cases, there is a cross pollination. It's hard enough to weather an overly sentimental attempt to pull at your shoestrings, as my girlfriend would say, but it's nigh impossible to tolerate two plot lines whose sole purpose is to warm the heart. Sometimes there is a diamond in the rough that actually takes the building blocks of these terrible genres and makes something special out of it. After all, the reason there are so many brainless copies is that initially these formulas work.
My relationship with Lucas started as something small, and slowly built into an obsession culminating in last night's viewing. The road to Lucas has been a rocky one, but well worth the journey. My ladyfriend loves movies and has withstood a barrage of films, ranging from The Godfather to Dead Heat, in my company. I sometimes feel like I'm overwhelming her with my crash course, but she sits through it with a grin. In many ways I feel like I'm working with a cinematic blank slate. She loves films, but has no frame of reference for anything. Her inability to make these connections fits with her charming, endearing personality, and it often leads to a cinematic scavenger hunt when trying to decipher a movie she's talking about.
One evening, she described to me and my roommate a film about a scrawny kid that wanted to play football. The kicker, no pun intended, was that he was "a little retarded". If you know my girlfriend, this could mean a wealth of things. Me and my friend nudged her until she admitted that perhaps he was just awkward. For whatever reason, my girlfriend finds awkwardness equatable to lower mental facilities. Also, she is unable to name or identify any actor since film was created. I like to tell her she couldn't pick Tom Hanks out of a lineup, to which she responds, "Hey, I know who that is! But that guy from all those shows..." However, she makes a good point. She often says she likes not knowing who anyone is because it completely convinces her they are whatever character they're playing. As far as she's concerned, Anthony Hopkins is some nice old man who never ate anyone's faces off.
The point I'm trying to make is, figuring out a movie she brings up is the ultimate test for a movie buff such as myself. There is so little to go on, other than your filmatic instinct. My roommate and I came to the conclusion that she was thinking of Rudy, the story of a shrimpy kid that wanted to play for Notre Dame. He had trouble making friends, was taunted, and played in the final game. It was also feasible that my girlfriend would think Sean Astin's portrayal of Rudy was "a little retarded", which amused me and my roommate to no end. Any time one of us said anything awkward or dumb, we were acting a little too "Rudy". My roommate also came from a family of Irish Notre Dame legacies, adding another level of comedy for him personally. Now, I've never actually seen Rudy, so I was pretty much guessing. I know it's supposed to be an uplifting sports film that actually succeeds, I knew the basic plot structure, and it seemed to fit my girlfriend's description.
Unfortunately, as time passed, she became less and less convinced it was Rudy. I couldn't let an inside joke of six months standing be negated! The search was back on, and at one time I was convinced it was the terrible John Irving adaptation Simon Birch, but apparently I was way off. For Laila, aka my girlfriend, aka the girl who has maintained her anonymity until now, the final piece of the puzzle was a burning jock strap. This scene stayed with her, and ultimately lead us to Lucas. As satisfying as it was to have the mystery solved, it was a bit of a letdown since I had never even heard of Lucas. I knew who Corey Haim was, but it was a complete mystery to me, which is pretty rare. We watched the trailer and first ten minutes on Youtube, and I knew I never wanted to see this movie as long as I lived. It slipped from our minds for a while until last night, when fate would bring us together once again.
Laila had actually had the foresight to record a showing of American Gangster, which she really wanted to see. This enthusiasm was rare, so like a complete asshole, I refused to watch it. I couldn't even explain to you why I didn't want to, I just didn't. She started to give me her patented "Big Eyes", which meant the hammer was coming down. I quickly scanned for something else to watch, and there it was. Lucas. Starting in one minute. She squealed in glee, and I knew the fates had dealt me a hand I couldn't fold. We turned off the lights, pulled up the blankets, and got ready for the one, the only, the little bit retarded, Lucas.
I liked it. I really fucking liked it! I hate that I liked it, and it stayed with me enough that I felt compelled to commit my opinion to the world wide web. The film starts off frustrating, and pretty much maintains that tone till the very end. That's one of the things that so smart about it. Lucas is pretty much a weird asshole the entire movie. I know I sure as hell wouldn't want to be friends with him, and I don't really blame people for being a little unnerved by a kid that crawls around sewers and collects bugs all day. However, some people aren't actually mean to him, and he is nice when unprovoked. He falls in love with a girl entirely out of his league, and she falls for the quarterback, who is actually nice to Lucas!
This is another thing about this film. Not everyone does things that you would expect, and it stays pretty true to life throughout. Lucas is weird, but funny enough that people do in fact tolerate him. The girl does not fall for him, and he is left alone. The last third of the film is dedicated to him trying to play football to win the girl back during the first game of the season. And you know what, he manages to sneakily get on to the field and play! He even manages to get thrown a touchdown pass, until he fumbles it, is tackled by ten guys twice his size, and is sent to the hospital. Sorry folks, if you were looking for an upbeat ending where he wins the game, no such luck. In fact, the entire football team completely sucks, and would have lost no matter what. And Lucas' mysterious rich parents? Just a drunk guy in a trailer park.
But you know what, Lucas manages to gain the respect of the school, and the film ends in a slow clap culminating in a freeze frame. This is probably the most cliched part of the movie, but I was glad to know Lucas wasn't shit on the entire time. Most of the film manages to play pretty truthfully to awkward high school social life, and as weird as he is, Lucas is relatable. I suppose the real success of Lucas is how unexpected it is. He doesn't particularly win anything, and he's borderline unlikeable, but this is what makes the film special. Was Lucas an underdog sports movie? Sort of. Was it a story of a kid who was a little retarded? Maybe. Lucas is hard to define, and that's what I loved about it. From now on, when Laila and I are being dumb and weird, we'll call each other Lucas, but with love and respect to the kid who may have murdered his alcoholic father.
